| |
Methods |
Strengths |
Limitations |
| |
|
Experiments
|
- Control over dependent variables and
the conditions for applying the experimental variable.
- Precision in measuring the dependent
and independent variables
- Provides rigorous tests of causal hypothesis
- High internal validity
- Easy to conduct, lowcost
|
- Possible difficulty in creating experimental
and control groups
- Low external validity (difficulty
in generalizing results)
|
|
|
- High on external validity
- Can be conducted in natural settings
- Can approach but not equal the
strengths of experiments
|
- Low on internal validity
- Difficulty of obtaining equivalent experimental
and control groups
|
|
|
- Simultaneous measurement of numerous
variables at one time
- Can provide multiple measurement of
the same indicator, closed and open-ended items can be
used in the same instrument
- Collection of data from large samples
- Provides descriptive information for
a large number of variables
- Data can be statistically analyzed
- Allows for generalization in populations
|
- Time consuming, can be expensive
- Limited level of measurement of variables
- Provides limited understanding of why
relationships occur
- Potential for reactivity
- Possible bias in constructing the questionnaire
- Possible bias in interviewing
- Difficulty in detecting inaccurate
or false responses
|
|
Available and secondary
data
(government reports, census data, data from a previous
surveys, mass media materials, etc.) |
- Non-reactive
- Can be done at the convenience of the
researcher
- Specific data can be used - dates, frequencies,
qualitative data
- Broad coverage, far more than a single
investigator could collect
- Provides data for trend studies
- Little or no cost involved
|
- Bias during collection of data unknown
- Data may be poor or invalid measures
of concepts on wants to measure
- May be difficult to access
|
|
|
- Focus on events as they happen
- Non-reactive
- See events in their natural social context
- Easily repeated for verification
- Excellent for exploring a topic
|
- Only a limited number of variables that
can be observed at one time
- Potential bias on the part of the observer
in observing, recording observations, analyzing and interpreting
data
- Limited to observation of small groups
in specific social setting
- Limited value for generalizing (based
on small groups, relatively few observations)
|
|
Participant observation
|
- Focus on real-life processes and events
- Descriptions of events in their
natural social context
|
- Time consuming, lengthy process
- Requires high level of skill and experience
- Potentially reactive
|