Methods for Social Researchers in Developing Countries




Multi-method
approach to research


Rapid rural appraisal

Strengths and limitations

Ethical issues


Aids

Home   TOC   Parts   Glossary   Links   References   Contact Us   Help

 

 
Methods
Strengths
Limitations
 


Experiments


  • Control over dependent variables and the conditions for applying the experimental variable.
  • Precision in measuring the dependent and independent variables
  • Provides rigorous tests of causal hypothesis
  • High internal validity
  • Easy to conduct, lowcost

  • Possible difficulty in creating experimental and control groups
  • Low external validity (difficulty in generalizing results)

Quasi-experiments

  • High on external validity
  • Can be conducted in natural settings
  • Can approach but not equal the strengths of experiments
  • Low on internal validity
  • Difficulty of obtaining equivalent experimental and control groups

Surveys

  • Simultaneous measurement of numerous variables at one time
  • Can provide multiple measurement of the same indicator, closed and open-ended items can be used in the same instrument
  • Collection of data from large samples
  • Provides descriptive information for a large number of variables
  • Data can be statistically analyzed
  • Allows for generalization in populations
  • Time consuming, can be expensive
  • Limited level of measurement of variables
  • Provides limited understanding of why relationships occur
  • Potential for reactivity
  • Possible bias in constructing the questionnaire
  • Possible bias in interviewing
  • Difficulty in detecting inaccurate or false responses

Available and secondary data
(government reports, census data, data from a previous surveys, mass media materials, etc.)

  • Non-reactive
  • Can be done at the convenience of the researcher
  • Specific data can be used - dates, frequencies, qualitative data
  • Broad coverage, far more than a single investigator could collect
  • Provides data for trend studies
  • Little or no cost involved
  • Bias during collection of data unknown
  • Data may be poor or invalid measures of concepts on wants to measure
  • May be difficult to access

Causal observation

  • Focus on events as they happen
  • Non-reactive
  • See events in their natural social context
  • Easily repeated for verification
  • Excellent for exploring a topic
  • Only a limited number of variables that can be observed at one time
  • Potential bias on the part of the observer in observing, recording observations, analyzing and interpreting data
  • Limited to observation of small groups in specific social setting
  • Limited value for generalizing (based on small groups, relatively few observations)
Participant observation
  • Focus on real-life processes and events
  • Descriptions of events in their natural social context
  • Time consuming, lengthy process
  • Requires high level of skill and experience
  • Potentially reactive

PREV       NEXT